Troy Story, Premiere (US), May 2004
By Fred Schruers
scans by Dri and Elf Lady
It isn’t pretty, what they’re doing to orlando bloom. he’s flung himself onto
the hard-packed Mexican dirt several times now, enacting the turning point of a
complex scene in which his character, Paris, has just taken a gawdalmighty
battering from Brendan Gleeson’s Menelaus.
The characters’ differences
are quite irreconcilable. The Trojan youth Paris, in this story that has
survived nearly three millennia, has stolen the Spartan King Menelaus’s wife,
Helen. With 50,000 of his fellow Greek warriors massed at the gates of Troy,
Menelaus has chosen this moment to make it personal. “Let me,” he’s just said to
his brother Agamemnon in the poetically tough-talking screenplay by David
Benioff (25th Hour), “kill this little peacock.”
Before the grudge
can be satisfied, Paris’s brother Hector, in the person of The Hulk’s
Eric Bana, will step in to save the lad. “For me,” says Bloom, “this scene is
the most intimidating part of this whole shoot, because I knew that I was going
to have to run from this moment—I just hobble and crawl away to my brother’s
feet. It’s just humiliation, the lowest possible point for a character to get
to.”
The shot that director Wolfgang Petersen (The Perfect Storm) is going
for at the moment comes just after Hector has dispatched Menelaus, and is
beseeching his younger brother to flee inside the gates even as the Greek
legions come on the run. But in a rash choice, the bloodied Paris sprints for
the stubby bronze sword of Troy that Menelaus had knocked from his grasp. The
shot will show one man running toward the angry horde. “Just when you think he’s
gone mad,” Petersen will later explain, “he’s turned it into the quite heroic
act of getting the sword of Troy.”
But Petersen isn’t quite seeing what he wants in Bloom’s gritty ten-yard
sprint and culminating dive to earth, and he calls for a cut in an assiduously
patient tone.
This is day 100 on one of the most expensive movie shoots ever. One insider
estimates production cost at $700,000 per day; add in other massive
below-the-line costs for ocean-spanning company moves and matériel, plus the
$17.5 million Brad Pitt will fetch for playing the tormented demigod Achilles,
and you’ve got something around a $200 million price tag.
It’s midafternoon on a typically oppressive 85 degree day here in Cabo San
Lucas, and even the normally roving local dogs are sprawled in the shade of the
gates of Troy, alongside a conked-out, burlap-clad extra who has succumbed to
the heat and perhaps a case of turistas. A few weeks ago the spot where
Bloom is literally hitting his mark was covered in brush, the property of a
cattle rancher named Atilo Colli. “They call him Capitain,” says local location
scout Luis Barrientos. “He’s got forty cows he loves like kids.” The property,
which is accessed by a dirt road crowded at points with crude huts and camper
shells used as homes, “wasn’t worth much until now,” notes Barrientos. Nearby,
the production has built an impressive naturalists’ lair where hired experts
tend the endangered local cacti, known as viejos, and plan strategies for
protecting the baby sea turtles that are just now entering their birthing
season.
As the scene is reset, Bloom stands inquisitively near Bana, with whom he’s
become good pals. “You look like you’ve got a basketball between your legs,” is
Bana’s tough-love assessment of the younger man’s dash, “or maybe a melon.”
“My legs are a bit bow,” says Bloom resignedly, then he addresses Petersen
more loudly, but neutrally: “Are we doin’ this again?”
Petersen gives him a wry nod. Bloom squints a bit to show that his next
question is only 25 percent or so humorous: “So, just . . . act . . .
better?”
“What can I say?” answers Petersen, who even in his floppy white sun hat
carries some of the elegance of a master of ceremonies in a Weimar nightclub.
“Just do it different.” Finally he gives in to the concept: “Better.”
Petersen, a veteran german theater director, first made his mark on
world cinema with Das Boot in 1981, and that model of undersea cinematic
claustrophobia wouldn’t seem a natural calling card for this sprawling epic that
he estimates to be “90 percent outdoors,” with early scenes filmed in Malta and
much of the Greek assault from beach to city shot here in Cabo, on a 2,800-acre
spread that boasts two miles of mostly untouched coastline. After the sub movie,
it took nearly a decade for the director to find real traction with In the
Line of Fire, followed by the middling Outbreak. But 1997’s Air
Force One earned more than twice its $85 million budget, and The Perfect
Storm was a global hit. Sheltered momentarily from the sun by a blue tarp,
Petersen, 63, considers what he’s taken on: “I’ve done big complicated movies,
but nothing of this score. It’s so complex. This is, so to speak, the big one
for me in the sense of the difficult logistics of it and everything. It’s very
challenging.”
The slate a crewman is marking up with black ink notes that the scene in
question is 94C. The prelude has been Hector intercepting Menelaus (“I’ll kill
him at your feet. I don’t care,” growls the cuckolded king) and plunging his
sword in until its hilt meets the king’s breastplate. (Some of the film’s spear
and sword strikes are done with telescoping blades and spear points; others will
be mimed thrusts with the nasty parts filled in via computer graphics.) Then, as
Benioff’s script describes it, Agamemnon (Menelaus’s brother and fellow general
in the Greek force, played by Brian Cox) shouts a wordless cry of rage and “the
entire Greek army surges forward . . . fifty thousand soldiers charge at Hector.
. . .”
What Petersen has, before the magic of computer-generated regiments, is one
one-hundredth of that number. He watches his first assistant director, Gerry
Gavigan, positioning the 500 extras for the charge up the hill. They are
outfitted variously as Myceneans, Spartans, Thessalonians, Ithacans, Salaminians
(led by Ajax, played by outsize actor Tyler Mane, a.k.a. Sabretooth in
X-Men), and, most fearsome, the black-clad Myrmidons (who are led by
Achilles, albeit not in today’s scene). The spear-carrying knot of 500 is there
to form the nucleus of a horde that will be multiplied by computer renderings in
the final picture. Standing nearby, visual-effects supervisor Nick Davis, much
honored for his work on Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, is
keenly interested in Petersen’s camera placement. “You have to look at each
camera and say, ‘No, that won’t work,’ or ‘Yes, we can do that.’ We’ve got one
superlong lens which will really stack [Bloom and Bana] up against the extras.
It will look great. And then the other shot, it’s ideal to get a wider lens
further and further away. There’s a lot of storytelling, a lot of beats that
need to happen between when that lot [he gestures toward the extras shambling
into place] charge and when they meet the Trojans here. And of course in
reality it’s not going to take them that long to get here. There’s a finite
stretch you can do before people say, ‘Nuh-uh, they’ve been running forever.’
”
In Davis’s favor is the innovative London effects house Moving Picture Company,
which is writing arcane strings of code designed to make computer-generated
warriors look real. “They’ve programmed an artificial intelligence system to
govern our armies,” he says. “We’ve done a huge amount of motion capture of
people running and charging and fighting and tripping, all the variations they
could do. Then we’ve written software that can take all that motion capture and
blend it together so the soldiers can think for themselves, go slower or faster,
and they can conform to a terrain. Every soldier has a slightly different shade,
every shield is slightly different, dented or dirty. And randomizations of
movement make it look real—it’s good to have one guy trip, then a lot of people
have to avoid him.”
Davis, Petersen, and director of photography Roger Pratt (12 Monkeys,
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets) discussed all this first thing
in the morning, as they always do. What Petersen’s chiefly hoping is that the
long lens sitting well behind Bloom and Bana, the one that will “stack” them
against the onrushing army to create a sense of urgency in the compressed space
that results, will lie for him: “It’s very tricky because on a shot like this,
these are fifty thousand, after CG. They’re advancing toward the twenty thousand
Trojans that are on this side. It’s more dramatic if there is not an endless gap
between these two armies.
“But what would it take in real time for an army to come from there to here?
Something like fifteen to twenty seconds? The scene [on film] will definitely be
a minute. So you cheat a little bit and stretch it and hopefully you find the
right amount of cuts so you can make it believable. It’s just finding out in the
editing room later on how much you can stretch it and where you really have to
say, ‘Okay, now they have to clash.’ ”
With a gesture to Gavigan, Petersen indicates that he wants to see the rush
of the meant-to-be-terrifying army. They’re huddled downslope on the dusty
field, mostly in comfortably breezy skirtlike getups that unfortunately are
topped by all manner of rubber and plastic armor. Put a man in a long, itchy wig
and a large, tight rubber helmet out in a field to kill time for 40 minutes
under the midday sun, and the production aides coming around with backpack rigs
full of water aren’t much consolation. Thick with local hires as well as a
sub-army of more than 200 Bulgarian jocks, the group is not quite surly but is
certainly far from ecstatic over being lined up to rehearse their uphill sprint.
They watch as the camera crew scrambles aboard a dolly rig that is to be
impelled alongside the charge—but they know that the money part of this shot,
Cox’s Agamemnon surging alongside in a chariot, will be filmed later. An
assistant director palavers to them in a tone that’s at once wheedling and
threatening, then hollers up the hill toward Gavigan: “What’s the cue,
Gerry?”
Gavigan, trained to respond quickly, barks out a not entirely commanding,
“Ummmm . . . ” A pause. “Charge! How about that?”
“Okay, here we go, boys,” hollers the AD. As the camera cart rolls, he gives
the order, and the 500 extras proceed to charge at baby turtle speed, with
anemic, not to say sardonic, battle cries. “Cut, cut, cut, cut, cut,” comes the
instruction, and then, a bit wearily, “Let’s go again.”
Petersen is unfazed. “It’s an extremely difficult movie, as I said. Such an
outdoor movie. You know how vulnerable you are as a production. A lot of people
get sick—a big problem we still have. Here especially, Montezuma’s revenge, the
stomach thing. It hits basically everybody. Some [are] in the hospital on an IV
drip. With these logistics and the sickness and the heat—I think what keeps us
going is that we have a really good movie. If there were any doubt about what we
are doing here, it would be almost impossible to go through this. It’s Homer,
it’s The Iliad. A wonderful combination of grand scale and intimate human
relations, a mutilayered story.” Preparing to head into the broiling sun and
survey both the troops and the shot, he gives a poker player’s twist of the
mouth, as if reminding himself of something that has served as daily
inspiration: “One of the great stories of all time.”
“I guess the best evidence of the power of the Trojan War myth,” says
David Benioff, “is that we’re still talking about it three thousand years
later.” Now one of the hotter screenwriters in Hollywood, with Marc Forster’s
Stay due later this year and a reconceiving of the classic For Whom
the Bell Tolls on his plate, he was still mostly a novelist looking to stray
(although he had adapted his own book The 25th Hour for Tobey Maguire’s
production shingle) when he walked into Warner Bros. executive Jeff Robinov’s
office in October 2001. It was the first such pitch meeting in his career. “I
was terrified, and not particularly articulate, I don’t think, and Jeff was kind
of staring at me. I was trying to make it sound eloquent, but it really felt
like I was blowing it,” he says. “I felt like, oh my God, I’ve taken this great
story and somehow made it seem unappealing. Because he’s got a great poker face.
He doesn’t give away anything.” Robinov asked Benioff to wait for a moment and
departed—to check, it would later emerge, with his then boss Lorenzo di
Bonaventura. “At the very end of the meeting, he said, ‘Are you ready to start
writing?’ And that was kind of a shock.”
Benioff’s story encompasses much more than Homer’s tale of the war; it also
used Virgil’s Aeneid and various histories. “The Iliad begins with
the rage of Achilles over Agamemnon’s abduction of a slave girl, Briseis. In my
script that doesn’t occur until page 82 or so. This is the Trojan War myth in
its entirety, and I’ve taken serious liberties, and been ruthless in terms of
what to cut out and what to change.”
The screenplay he came up with was so clean that Warner Bros. took the
extremely rare step of sending it right out to Petersen,whose Radiant
Productions has a deal with the studio, and around the same time slipped a copy
to Pitt.
Pitt had all but signed on when he met up with Petersen: “We had a nice
dinner in a German restaurant in L.A. called Black Forest, having a good time
with very heavy German food and some beers,” the director recalls. “We talked
about the script and the part and got very excited about it. We talked also
about Eric Bana, who I had met in the meantime—Brad had also seen his film
Chopper—and we both had the feeling that he could be a great Hector. And
then came the long hard work of casting the other parts.”
Bana, a formidable presence at 34 (when he was cast), needed a younger
brother who shared at least some of his chiseled features but could be the
sheltered neophyte to his veteran soldier—and the impetuous lover to the most
dangerously beautiful woman in the world. Bloom, then 25, had burst onto the
scene just months before as the earnestly heroic Legolas in The Lord of the
Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring. He’d also had a small part in Black
Hawk Down, as the trooper who slips from a rope (much as, in real life, he
once had a near-catastrophic fall from a drainpipe)—but otherwise he was
untested. In a meeting at London’s Dorchester hotel with Petersen and producer
Diana Rathbun, he was, Rathbun recalls, “most articulate; he really understood
the torment of Paris, you could see it in his face as he spoke, see it take
hold.”
Recent history has of course shown their wisdom. During the weeks when Bloom was
on theater screens alongside Johnny Depp in the blockbuster Pirates of the
Caribbean (Pirates and each LOTR installment have earned more
than $300 million), most Internet film and fan sites were getting as many hits
for him as they were for Depp and other, more ephemeral Web sensations. His
stardom by now seems assured, and, to most observers, likely to last; after
Troy, he has no fewer than four projects in various stages of production,
including the leading role in the Crusades drama Kingdom of Heaven for
his Black Hawk Down director, Ridley Scott.
Before long, Petersen had rounded out his cast with Bloom’s LOTR
compatriot Sean Bean as Odysseus, 19-year-old discovery Garrett Hedlund as
Achilles’s impetuous younger cousin Patroclus, Gladiator veteran John
Shrapnel as the battle-savvy Greek Nestor, James Cosmo (Braveheart) as
Trojan general Glaucus, and the venerated Peter O’Toole and Julie Christie as
King Priam of Troy and Achilles’s mother, Thetis. Then came the search that
would allow the director to brag, quite accurately, “We have so many beautiful
women here.” The willowy Saffron Burrows (Enigma) was cast as Hector’s
wife, Andromache, and Australian ingenue Rose Byrne, after being discussed for
the Helen role, was signed to play the slave girl Briseis. “Only Briseis calms
Achilles down and pulls him back to earth,” says Petersen, and Byrne agrees: “He
lets his guard down a bit around her—not a lot, but it shows his humane,
vulnerable side.”
Finally, the epic needed the woman who intoxicates young prince Paris and
thereby spurs all that follows. “All the blood, all the violence of the war was
initiated by a passionate love story,” says Petersen. Helen of Troy had to be
otherworldly, a blond aberration among the swarthy Greeks; with her lambent
blue-green eyes and aristocratic bearing, German model-turned-actress Diane
Kruger won the day (see story on page 50).
In keeping with Petersen’s wish for “fresh faces,” it was not, other than
Pitt, the costliest cast. But as Warner Bros. prepped the budget with Rathbun,
they watched the cost inevitably rise. The drumbeats leading to the U.S.
invasion of Iraq were unmistakable, and with so much uncertainty and possible
turmoil, Morocco was scrapped as a location for the months of work by a beach.
Massive props were broken down and crated for the move to Cabo San Lucas in the
bellies of Russian Antonov transport planes. One of these was the 40-foot-high
Trojan horse, with which the Greeks manage to penetrate the city’s defenses. It
had played its part well in Malta, as Bean recalls: “I was expecting a trap
door, but we actually came through doors in the horse’s neck, side, and flanks.
It looked like it was all covered in insects.”
For the cast and crew who were simply moving from one scorchingly hot coastline
to another, the decampment to Mexico was hardly a holiday—even though Cabo has
become a noted vacation destination. The work in Malta had been marred by one
tragedy—bodybuilder George Camilleri was injured in a waterborne action
sequence, and 18 days after a pin was inserted in his badly broken leg, he
somewhat mystifyingly died. There was also the hard-to-assess PR debacle of
widely circulated paparazzo photos of Pitt, helmetless and casual, gams
attractively bare, talking on a cell phone in the Maltese sun.
There’s no escaping that much of the weight of properly bringing off this
staggeringly expensive epic rests on Pitt’s portrayal of Achilles, whom Petersen
calls “a haunted guy, not necessarily really happy.” Petersen grants the
skeptics their question—“I would say normally, ‘Is that Brad, can he pull that
off? Does he have that kind of dark side to him?’ ” But, he adds, “He absolutely
has. I think Brad had from the very beginning a very strong instinct about how
to play this part. He felt as an actor that he was born to do this. At some
point he even said to Peter O’Toole, ‘All the parts I [ever] did were like a
preparation for this part.’ His whole demeanor every single day here—his
physical preparation, his mental preparation, the fact that he stopped smoking
for it—he did everything to get ready for the part and into the part.”
On Super Bowl Sunday, Pitt leveled a sword at a huge worldwide TV audience in
a Troy trailer and promised an unseen Agamemnon, “Before my time is done,
I will look down on your corpse and smile.” Petersen, who watched a cast of
mainly British actors easily spout the lines in the production’s haute-English
style (what’s called Received Pronunciation), admits that for Pitt, “there was
maybe some struggle from the very beginning, finding the right dialect. But he
got control of that very quickly and from that, following the mission of being
the greatest warrior of all time.”
As Petersen worked through key sequences in the movie, important Achilles
scenes were stacked toward the shoot’s last days—including a postcoital moment
with Briseis, an epochal battle with Hector, and a poignant encounter with
Priam, who pleads for a slain warrior’s body. The battle in fact had to await a
major set rebuilding after a hurricane hit Cabo, as well as downtime after Pitt,
in a costly coincidence, hurt his Achilles tendon.
Pitt wasn’t alone in being challenged. Bana brooded at length before
accepting the Hector role. “It’s the process of convincing yourself that you’re
up to it,” he says, “because if you can’t do it you’re going to make a
monumental cock of yourself.”
Since shooting started, Bana has had no regrets. He came to regard screen
brother Bloom “as like a real brother,” and was delighted to work opposite the
legendary O’Toole. “To perform scenes with someone you feel genuine affection
for . . . because Orlando’s playing my brother, Peter’s playing my father, and
I’ve had some stuff with Peter inside the scene as we were playing—just really
special,” he says. “We had an amazing scene this week, just before I go off to
battle Achilles—bidding farewell to my immediate family. Peter’s character is
about the only one I allow Hector to show any emotion toward, so it was just
really nice, a total no-acting-required moment.”
From the moment when Bloom and Bana first met—a practice horseback ride in
London, with plenty of excited speculation about the film (“Two boys on their
horses, talking about the adventure to come,” recalls Bloom), and cigars and
more talk after—the bonding has been unequivocal. “I look up to him, a real
honorable man,” Bloom says of his costar. “Like Hector is to Paris, he’s a real
rock.”
As Bloom sits talking, studiously ignoring the long gash the makeup crew has
created on his right thigh, he’s mindful that “I still have to shoot this scene
where I see my brother go out to fight Achilles. Hector is an honorable and
skillful and brave and strong fighter, you know. But Achilles is just a killer.
So when he goes out to fight—I still have to play this moment where I see my
brother do what I should have done.”
“Paris is a very different role for Orlando Bloom,” says Benioff. “Obviously
he was the kind of fearless hero in The Lord of the Rings who gets to run
up an elephant and shoot an arrow in his brain. And here, yeah, he is showing
fear. I would just say in defense of Paris, I mean, I don’t think many of us
have had to walk across a field facing a large angry man with a sharp sword who
wants us dead because we stole his wife.”
“Amidst this epic, fantastic, huge sort of drama,” says Bloom, “it’s very
human at the crux of it. It deals with very human issues: anger, hate, love,
fear, and all those things that lead a man to war, lead a country to war.
“As a young prince, Paris has been protected by the umbrella of that family
and that environment,” he adds. “He’s an archer, which is more of a sport, and
he’s never really taken up a blade. He’s left it up to his older brother to be
the warrior. He’s a complex character, an antihero, dark. There are certainly a
lot of dark qualities about him because of the decision he makes.”
Despite his treatment at the hands of Menelaus, Paris will live to fight on
for Troy. In fact, those archery skills will, as readers versed in Homer’s story
well know, lead to a crucial enemy’s death in a way that’s anything but gentle.
Just as Brian Cox’s Agamemnon was induced to slaughter a hugely sympathetic
character in the person of a man he much admires—“It was nerve-wracking,” he
says. “On my first day I killed one of my icons”—Bloom must unleash his arrows
at Pitt’s Achilles. “He’s a demigod, the most incredible warrior known to man,
and the fact that I have to [do that] was such a challenge—to try and make an
audience understand the motives behind this character’s actions so they don’t
completely despise him. In the same way that for Joaquin Phoenix in
Gladiator his actions were based in greed, envy, and lust, wanting
something else, Paris is trying to . . .”
Bloom pauses as a seabreeze that’s accompanying the arrival of dusk sends a
half-hearted dust devil across the ground toward him. Just behind it is an
assistant director coming to say Bloom is wrapped for the day. Many a young
actor would be halfway to the trailer in a heartbeat, heading for the hotel pool
and a beer, but Bloom politely asks for a moment and walks a few paces to get
his benediction from Petersen. He gives an inquiring look, ready for a last
thought, but the director just gazes back with obvious fondness and gives him an
acknowledging nod. Well, then, Bloom’s manner seems to say, as he brings forth
his hand with a slightly formal hitching motion to shake Petersen’s. “A pleasure
doin’ business with ya, boss,” he says. Trudging through the giant plaster
construction that is the city gate, he finishes his interrupted thought: “Paris
is a young man, and I’m a young man. And as a young man, you’re coming to terms
with an awful lot that you battle with. It’s the seven deadly sins, you know,
everyone’s trying to understand what they mean to him. And so it’s been a
challenge.” He waits a beat, making sure of eye contact so it’s understood that
if the next words are the expected ones, they’re not empty: “But a really
exciting one.”